Home | Blog | Defense of Marriage Act held unconstitutional

Defense of Marriage Act held unconstitutional

A federal district court in New York (southern district New York) has held that a portion of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) is unconstitutional.   The issue in the case was whether the estate of a decedent would claim the unlimited marital deduction for that portion of the estate passing to a same-sex surviving spouse.

The court found that DOMA denied the surviving spouse of the right to equal protection of the laws as guaranteed by the Fifth Amendment to the US Constitution. Prior to this case a marital deduction was only allowed if the surviving spouse was a partner in a heterosexual marriage.

This case does not impact any of the other requirements necessary to obtain the marital deduction, including the requirement that the surviving spouse be a US citizen.

This case has no precedential authority outside the southern district of New York.

There is no indication yet as to whether the United States will appeal this decision.

Edith Schlain Windsor, Plaintiff v. The United States of America, Defendant.  US District Court, S.D. New York. 2012 U.S.T.C. P60,647 (6 June, 2012)

Here to Help

Here to Help

Contact one of our specialists

London
USTAXFS
3 Harbour Exchange Square
London E14 9GE
United Kingdom

T: +44 20 7357 8220

F: +44 20 7357 8225

Email Us

Zurich
USTAXFS
Brandschenkestrasse 20
CH-8001 Zurich
Switzerland

T: +41 44 387 8070

F: +41 44 387 8079

Email Us

Geneva
USTAXFS
Rue de-Candolle 19
CH 1205
Geneva
Switzerland

T: +41 22 700 2500

F: +41 22 700 2526

Email Us

Middle East, Asia and the Americas
US Tax & Financial Services GmbH
Löwenstrasse 28
PO Box 1367
CH-8021 Zurich
Switzerland

T: +41 44 387 8070

F: +41 44 387 8079

Email Us

Nordics
USTAXFS / MAJATTORNEY
Norra Skeppsbron 5B
SE 803 10, GAVLE
Sweden

T: +46 26 18 82 22

M: +46 70 61 88 016

Email Us

Read Services in :EnglishFrenchItalianGerman